TDCAA Community
discharge from "straight" probation. Conviction or not?

This topic can be found at:
http://tdcaa.infopop.net/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/157098965/m/2217087616

June 20, 2019, 15:30
Hubert
discharge from "straight" probation. Conviction or not?
Does discharge from "Straight" probation result in a conviction? I believe it can be.... I have a Defendant who completed felony probation for Assault of a Family Member - impeding airway. On the "order of discharge", there are two pre-printed blocks. One states, "Defendant discharged from Probation; or" the next one states, "Defendant discharged from probation. The Court FURTHER ORDERS that the Defendant's plea be withdrawn and the verdict set aside. The Court FURTHER ORDERS.....", Since the 1st block was checked, I believe it is still a conviction, suitable for enhancement. Opinions?
June 20, 2019, 15:40
Jon English
It’s still a conviction, but not a “final conviction” for enhancement purposes.
June 20, 2019, 15:44
Jon English
Wait, sorry. Didn’t see this was a special offense (Family Violence). Yes, I think it counts for enhancement purposes because we’re not dealing with Chapter 12 enhancements.
June 20, 2019, 15:48
Hubert
OK, so we are saying that 1. it IS a conviction for use when enhancing new family violence offenses but 2. NOT a "final" conviction that can be used for enhancing under 12.42?
June 20, 2019, 15:57
Hubert
Ex parte Jeremy Pue. https://law.justia.com/cases/t...18/wr-85-447-01.html - this supports that interpretation (p.7). So, why the different wording? Is there any practical difference? Sorry, just had some time and am trying a little higher thinking.....
June 21, 2019, 11:19
Shannon Edmonds
Probation set-asides, aka "judicial clemency," have been on the books for decades. The current version is CCP Art. 42A.701(f). They are rarely used, but if a judge sets aside a probation, it cannot be used as the basis for, say, a felon in possession of a weapon charge.

A 2017 bill required set-aside language to be included in all plea paperwork, judgments, and probation forms, in an effort to increase their use. #smartoncrime
July 16, 2019, 12:26
JohnR
quote:
Originally posted by Shannon Edmonds:
Probation set-asides, aka "judicial clemency," have been on the books for decades. The current version is CCP Art. 42A.701(f). They are rarely used...

Your mileage may vary. In one county where I practiced, the set aside language was a part of every probation discharge, even for cases where it does not apply, e.g. DWI. In my current county, we had a rash of them a few years ago after the defense bar started talking about them.