TDCAA Community
DNA by Business Records

This topic can be found at:
https://tdcaa.infopop.net/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/157098965/m/578107931

April 19, 2004, 13:36
East Texas Attorney
DNA by Business Records
I'm prosecuting an Agg Sex Asslt case were daddy got his daughter pregnant. DNA of the child was sent to an independent lab. 99.99% granddaddy is daddy. We have the DNA as a business record. We're trying to save money by not have lab techs testify and use the business record. Cole v State refers to a DPS lab as a branch of law enforcement. I have found Caw v. State regarding an independent lab. Does anyone see a problem in going this way or is there anyone who has proceeded in this manner? Also, would there be a Daubert challenge?
April 19, 2004, 16:42
Versel
As a former criminal defense attorney, I would suggest not saving money this way. Not only would I attack the last chain in your chain of custody if no one from the lab testifies, I would object to you "reading anything" into the results. In other words, without an expert to explain exactly what the results mean, I would object to the D.A. or any other non-expert explaining it to the jury. This is, assuming, you could get past a Daubert challenge to begin with.
April 19, 2004, 16:48
Ken Sparks
If the defense does not object 10 days prior to trial, you can file affidavits that would be admissible under the above provisions.